[Right_to_die] Pain control no better
ergo at efn.org
Sat Jul 24 09:18:25 PDT 2004
Study says pain control isn't better
An OHSU study finds that pain management has not kept up with expectations
of the 1997 law
Friday, July 23, 2004
Pain relief for dying patients in Oregon has not kept up with rising
expectations and even may have faltered in recent years, a new study
Dying patients are nearly twice as likely to experience moderate or severe
pain during the last week of life, as reported by surviving relatives,
compared with patients before the Oregon Death With Dignity Act took effect
in late 1997, the study found.
"End-of-life care has not been 'fixed,' and there is plenty of room for
improvement, particularly in the final week of life," a team of Oregon
Health & Science University researchers concluded.
The findings call into question the widespread view that pain control at the
end of life has improved markedly in Oregon. They were published in the
Journal of Palliative Medicine.
Researchers said the contradiction may be partly explained by rising
expectations about pain control since the high-profile debate and publicity
about the Oregon law. Stretched budgets for care of Medicare and Medicaid
patients also may be involved, they said.
"What this study did for me was contrast our view of things versus what's
actually happening," said Dr. Erik Fromme, who led the research. Fromme is
an assistant professor of general medicine and geriatrics at OHSU and senior
scholar in its Center for Ethics in Health Care.
The findings, he said, "are not necessarily what people wanted to hear."
They raise a troubling question for people who deliver -- or receive --
end-of-life care: Has the actual quality of care, including pain relief,
failed to keep pace with rising public expectations for a painless death?
The OHSU study deals with deaths outside the hospital: at home, in nursing
homes or assisted living centers -- any of which may include hospice care.
Family members rated their dying relative's pain during the final week of
life. Researchers compared 340 deaths from 1996-97 with 1,384 deaths from
2000-02. They found a startling difference: 48 percent of the later patients
were said to be in moderate or severe pain, compared with 31 percent in the
After accounting for medical and demographic differences between the two
groups, researchers found that dying patients in the later period were about
twice as likely to be described as having moderate or severe pain.
Oregon is the only state in which a doctor can legally prescribe a lethal
dose of medication to a terminally ill patient of sound mind who makes the
request in writing and meets certain other requirements. The Oregon Death
With Dignity Act took effect after a fierce public debate, court challenges
and two ballot measures.
Fromme said there is no doubt that the public debate over doctor-assisted
suicide and its alternatives in Oregon raised the public consciousness of
the need for better pain control at the end of life. Studies since then have
suggested that both doctors and patients are more aware of the importance of
pain relief. Oregon ranks high among states in use of strong painkillers,
such as morphine, and rates of hospice enrollment.
Those changes have not reached all areas of the state equally, Fromme said.
"People all around the state have heard the publicity, but they haven't
necessarily gotten better care. If people's expectations are higher, I'm
glad," he said. "But in addition to expecting more, I hope they'll push the
health care providers to get them the care and pain relief they need."
The results point out how important it is for patients and families "to be
constantly vigilant" when it comes to pain and end-of-life care, said Ann
Jackson, executive director of the Oregon Hospice Association. Otherwise,
she said, "the system default is to do as little as possible."
Two factors may have discouraged doctors from prescribing adequate pain
medication, she said. First, controversy over the misuse and addictiveness
of the prescription narcotic OxyContin scared doctors and patients.
Second, the Bush administration's effort to quash the Oregon Death With
Dignity Act may have had a chilling effect. U.S. Attorney General John
Ashcroft wrote a memo in 2001 that Oregon doctors could be prosecuted for
violating federal drug laws if they prescribed a lethal dose of medication
in response to a patient's request under the Oregon law.
Oregon challenged the opinion in court and, so far, has prevailed. But the
court fight made some doctors skittish about prescribing strong pain drugs,
Another factor is the budgetary strain on nursing resources. "The negative
impact of overstretching nursing resources on pain management should not be
underestimated," the OHSU study found.
The research was funded by OHSU, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, the
Greenwall Foundation, the Open Society Institute's Project on Death in
America, the Meyer Memorial Trust and the National Institute of Nursing
Don Colburn: 503-294-5124; doncolburn at news.oregonian.com.
More information about the org.opn.lists.right-to-die